Which Beatrix Potter 50p Coins are the scarcest?

With Monday’s announcement of four new Beatrix Potter 50p coins leading to as many as 50,000 collectors queuing at The Royal Mint’s website to reserve the coins online, Change Checker can reveal which of last year’s 5 Beatrix Potter circulation 50p coins are currently the most sought after by collectors.

Using data unique collecting and swap data, Change Checker will be publishing its first-ever 50p “Scarcity Index” later this month but ahead of the full publication, we can give you a sneak preview as to which of last year’s Beatrix Potter 50p coins are currently most sought after by collectors.

How rare are the Beatrix Potter 50p coins?

Final mintages are yet to be published but the Change Checker “Scarcity Index” scores each of the UK’s 54 circulation 50p coin designs out of 100 to determine their relative scarcity.

Results suggest that Jemima Puddle-Duck is currently the 6th most difficult coin to find in your change, with Squirrel Nutkin coming in close behind.  Peter Rabbit has certainly become easier over the last few months but still sits 20th out 54 issues.

How valuable are my Beatrix Potter 50p coins?

Currently you can still buy base metal collector versions of the Beatrix Potter 50p coins direct from the Royal Mint for £10 and Change Checker Certified Brilliant Uncirculated versions for £3.99, rather than wait to find them in your change.  That has meant that their values have been pretty much capped.

But The Royal Mint has confirmed that they are not striking any more 2016 collector editions, which means that when current stocks of the Brilliant Uncirculated version are exhausted, collectors’ only choice will be to search for circulation versions. 

So whilst the 2016 Beatrix Potter 50p coins are not likely to follow the example of the ultra-rare Kew Gardens 50p, which achieves prices of between £70 and £100, collectors may see prices rise from around 6 times face value to somewhere between 10 and 12 times face value over the coming months.

But don’t forget, the joy of Change Checking is that you may receive a Beatrix Potter 50p coin in your change at any time for just its face value – 50p. 

How Peter Rabbit changed British Coin Collecting

peter-rabbitOn 29 February 2016 UK coin collecting was changed forever.

It wasn’t changed by a new currency, a new coin specification, or even a new denomination.

It was changed by a small rabbit.  A rabbit called “Peter”.


Change Checkers chose the Beatrix Potter 50p Coins as their coin story of the year.

Of course, Peter is no ordinary rabbit.  He’s the naughty rabbit at the centre of Beatrix Potter’s beloved children’s stories.

And so it was no surprise when Change Checkers voted the UK’s new Beatrix Potter coins as the coin collecting story of the year with  almost twice as many votes as the next rival.

But why has Peter Rabbit and Friends piqued a nation’s collecting fervour when dozens of other coins have barely passed mention?

  1. An established tradition of collecting and gifting

    Go to your kitchen cupboard or sideboard.  Pull out the things you use every day and rummage around in the back.  I’ll bet you 50p (although maybe not a Peter Rabbit one) that’ll you’ll pull out a Peter Rabbit cup or plate – perhaps Wedgwood or Royal Doulton.  And it’s equally likely to be from your childhood as your children’s (if you have them).

    Walk into a baby’s nursery and the same applies.  The Tales of Peter Rabbit and Friends adorn the shelves.  Not so much as literary treat at bedtime but much more an ornament designed to reflect a wholesome and traditional childhood.

    Whether, books, plates, figurines or plush, nearly all of us have grown up with Peter Rabbit collectables, and still today, when seeking a new baby, first birthday or Christening gift, we turn to the works of Beatrix Potter.

  2. Incredible news coverage

    It’s unusual to wake up to see a new British coin hitting the headlines of the morning’s newspapers and being the conversation point on the breakfast show sofas.  But Peter Rabbit did just that.


    The Silver 50p crashed the Royal Mint’s website

    However, it was not the base metal coin that would enter circulation that was causing all the excitement.  Instead it was the Limited Edition Silver Proof Coin.  And it wasn’t just Peter capturing the nation’s imagination, it was the fact that he had been finished in colour – the first time the main element of a British coin has ever been coloured.

    That was enough to get the story out there.  EVERYWHEREBy mid-morning The Royal Mint’s website had crashed under the sheer weight of the public’s interest.  The Mint suddenly had to limit numbers and in little more than a few hours all 15,000 coins were completely sold out.

    Suddenly the sell out consolidated demand and interest for the base metal Peter Rabbit coin, as well as the three further issues of 2015 – Squirrel Nutkin, Mrs Tiggy-Winkle and Jemima Puddle-Duck.

    Excitement increased even more, when The Royal Mint announced that they would make an early release of the circulation coins in just 5 locations with links to Beatrix Potter.  But how would it last?  Would the Peter Rabbit 50p become a valuable modern classic?

  1. Add eBay Fuel to the media fire

    Of course, a few years ago the story may have come and gone as quickly as Peter Rabbit scurrying out of Mr McGregor’s garden.  But not in 2016.

    As stories of shortages grew, collectors turned to eBay to sell not only the scarce Silver 50p but also the Royal Mint base metal packs – all at a massive premium.  Online auctions in May were showing circulation coins achieving sale prices north of £30.00, whilst crazy listings had “buy-it-now” prices closer to £100.

    And so the collecting frenzy continued to spiral, with journalists returning to the story that had first whet their appetites in February as a new coin, bringing it back to life as the new “rare coin” to enter circulation.

So what’s the truth behind the Beatrix Potter 50p Coin?

Firstly, it’s fair to say that the Silver Coin is very scarce.  All 15,000 were sold to individual collectors and getting hold of one now is extremely difficult.  One established London coin dealer is currently offering them for a minimum of £580 in original Royal Mint packaging.

As for the base metal version of the coin, it is also destined to be one of the most wanted circulating coins of all time.  It has, after all, been the most requested swap on Change Checker for the last 6 months – breaking all previous records.

However, buyer beware.  At the moment you can still by mint condition brilliant uncirculated Beatrix Potter 50p coins in official Royal Mint Presentation Packs for £10 or Change Checker Certified Brilliant Uncirculated Coins for just £3.99.  And, of course, you still have the chance of finding one in your change for just 50p.

So for now, avoid being blinded by the hype – the most you need to pay today is just £3.99.

But there is some magic here.  The combination of a deep collectable heritage, a growing national fascination in coins, and a spiralling of demand has made Peter Rabbit (along with Squirrel Nutkin, Mrs Tiggy-Winkle and Jemima Puddle-Duck) a true collecting sensation.

And I can’t believe that’s about to die away.  For me it’s a certainty that the 2016 Peter Rabbit 50p coins will quickly disappear from circulation, destined to become one of the rarest and most sought-after 50p coins ever issued.

At the same time, it’s created many thousands more pocket change collectors, not just fascinated by Peter Rabbit and Friends but also by the 100 plus other designs that help define our nation.

Well done Royal Mint – and, of course, a small nod to Beatrix Potter too.

Still Available – the complete range of Beatrix Potter 50p Coins from just £3.99